9th-12th Grade
Subjects:
Arts, Language Arts, Library / Technology, Philanthropy and Social Studies
Key Words/Concepts click to view
| ART: | Music: History/Culture; Visual Arts: Analyze |
| ELA: | Brainstorming; Compare/Contrast; Ethics; Listening; Questioning; Reading; Stereotyping/Bias |
| PHIL: | Altruism; Culture; Discrimination; Egoism; Minorities; Respect; Self Interest; Selflessness; Stereotypes; Tolerance |
| SOC: | Compare/Contrast; Consensus; Discrimination; Diversity; Ethics; LEAGUE Optional Lesson: King Day; Minorities; Racism |
Purpose:
Students will define stereotype, discrimination and prejudice. They will brainstorm a social action plan to heal racism.
Duration:
Three Fifty-Five Minute Class Periods
Objectives:
The learners will:
- differentiate between misperceptions and actual demographics about population, health, wealth and resources.
- illustrate a stereotype and identify stereotypes illustrated by other students.
- describe the role of racial identity in his or her life.
- compare, contrast and interpret national and classroom statistics on hate.
- define stereotype, discrimination, prejudice, egoism and altruism and recognize discrimination.
- describe the origins of prejudice and list ways to heal racism.
- create a personal social action plan for healing racism.
Materials:
- Student copies of The Herman Grid (see Bibliographical References)
- If the World Were 100 People (Attachment One)
- The book If the World Were a Village (optional)
- If the World Were 100 People Answer Key (Attachment Two)
- Papers with stereotypes and numbers in the corner
- Pencils, markers, erasers, blank paper and tape
- Racial Identity Autobiography Guidelines and Rubric (Attachment Three)
- Transparency or large copy of Don’t Laugh at Me song lyrics
- The National Hate Test (Attachment Four)
- The National Hate Test Answer Key (Attachment Five)
- Stand and Deliver Activity (Attachment Six)
- “Healing Racism: Education’s Role” (see Bibliographical References)
- Healing Racism Action Plan (Attachment Seven)
Instructional Procedure(s):
Day One:
Anticipatory Set:
Pass out copies of the Herman Grid to each learner. Ask the learners to share their impressions of what they see. Then, ask if they see gray dots at the white intersections. Are the gray dots really there? How does the Herman Grid represent our self-betrayal and/or self-deception? What do the boxes represent? What do the gray dots represent? How might the Herman Grid be interpreted on an individual, school, community, state, country and world level? The gray dots are an example of how we sometimes see things that are not really there (misperceptions) when we are trapped in our boxes.
-
“Stereotyping:” Explain that the learners will take a look at some of their perceptions about the world and compare them with actual world demographics about population, health, wealth and resources. Distribute the If the World Were 100 People worksheet (Attachment One) to each learner. Break the learners into groups of four or five to discuss answers, reach consensus and complete the worksheet. A recorder from each group should come to the board and write the statistics their group chose for each item on the worksheet. When all groups have written their information on the board, the teacher should write the actual statistics (Attachment Two) and have the class discuss why the actual statistics may vary from the student responses.
-
According to the statistics, which ethnic group(s) is (are) a minority (minorities)?
- Which country has all of the wealth?
- Ask the learners what surprised them the most about these statistics. Why? (Note: Generally students are surprised by the low statistic for the white population in the world and the wealth statistics.)
- How does surprise at these statistics relate to perceptions and misperceptions?
- If our perceptions about the world are not accurate, then how accurate are our perceptions of our own country, state, community, school and other individuals? (Note: The teacher may want to read the book, If the World Were a Village, to the students at this time, but it is not included in this lesson as an essential step.)
- Tell the students that they will be doing a fun drawing exercise that will explore their perceptions of other people on a smaller scale. They will have only ten minutes to draw. Give each student a piece of paper on which they will draw a specific subject (written in a corner and folded to the back of the paper so that others are not able to see it). The goal is to draw a picture that provides clues to the rest of the class so that they will be able to identify the subject. Each paper will also have a number on it. When students have finished drawing their pictures they are to tape them up in the room in the area designated for their number.
(Teacher Note: Write the numbers and subjects on the papers prior to distributing them. Possible stereotypes might include: teacher, environmentalist, business professional, welfare mother, skater, garbage man, senior citizen, teenager, political activist, drug user, homeless person, computer programmer, drug dealer, service-learning practitioner, biker, interior decorator, librarian, politician, truck driver, single father, alcoholic/wino, punk rocker. The teacher should modify the list to meet the specific community/school population. There may be more than one picture per number area.)
- When all drawings are complete, ask the class:
-
Who do you think this is?
-
Are stereotypes harmful? Helpful?
-
How do they get started?
-
Are they always true?
-
Are there exceptions?
-
The goal is to help students see that we all have stereotypes and we all recognize stereotypes.
-
Ask the learners how they think stereotyping originated. How did their own racial identities evolve? Have students write an autobiography based on their racial identities for homework using Racial Identity Autobiography Guidelines and Rubric (Attachment Three). This will lay the groundwork for developing ways to heal racism.
Day Two:
- “Discrimination”: As students enter the classroom, display the lyrics to the song, “Don’t Laugh at Me” while the homework assignments are collected. Ask students what they feel the theme is. Then, explain to the students that they will be exploring discrimination of all types.
- Give each student a copy of The National Hate Test (Attachment Four) and give them about ten minutes to complete it. Collect the papers. Explain that the scores will be tallied per item and then compared and contrasted to the national statistics the next day. See The National Hate Test Answer Key (Attachment Five).
- Do the Stand and Deliver Activity (Attachment Six). It may take 20-25 minutes. Total silence and seriousness during the activity is extremely important to its effectiveness. Debriefing is imperative as some students may be emotional. Debrief by asking:
- What are some feelings that came up for you during this activity?
- What was the hardest part for you?
- What did you learn about yourself? About others?
- What was your biggest surprise during this experience?
- What did this activity show you about discrimination?
- Keeping this in mind, Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr. said: “Let us rise up tonight with a great readiness. Let us stand with a greater determination. And let us move on in these powerful days, these days of challenge, to make America what it ought to be.” In your opinion, what else do we need to know in order to begin healing racism?
Day Three:
- Share the results of the class’ National Hate Test using The National Hate Test Answer Key (Attachment Five) and compare/contrast to the national statistics. Discuss those statistics that indicate stereotyping, discrimination and prejudice exist in their lives.
- Read the Rosa Parks quote: “Each person must live their life as a model for others.” Briefly explain egoism as a theory that human beings act or should act in their own interests and desires. Egoism is frequently associated with the early Greek hedonists, whose aim was pursuing pleasure and avoiding pain. Define altruism as a belief that human beings should act in ways that help others. It is also a selfless concern for the welfare of others. Ask students in which category Rosa Park’s actions belong. Distribute the Healing Racism Action Plan (Attachment Seven) for students to complete and turn in. This enables them to begin to brainstorm individually their role in making change through altruism.
- For homework, have students draw a plan of the tables in the cafeteria and identify where various groups locate (both race/ethnic and/or social cliques). Explain that there is actually a day when groups “Mix It Up” at lunch to heal racism. (See http://www.tolerance.org/teach/.) This will be a future activity in this unit.
Assessment:
- Racial Identity Autobiography scored with a rubric
- Brief oral presentation of information in reading
- Diagram of cafeteria with ethnic and/or social groups shown
School/Home Connection:
Interactive Parent / Student Homework:
- Day One: Ask students to write a two to four paragraph autobiography based on their racial identities. They will answer questions about ways it has influenced them. The order that the students answer these questions is their choice and the autobiography should not be written simply as numbered answers to the questions (Attachment Three). The teacher will score according to the attached rubric.
- Day Three: Have students diagram the cafeteria with ethnic and/or social groups shown.
Bibliographical References:
Lesson Developed and Piloted by:
Gail Tuthill
St. Charles Community Schools
St. Charles High School
St. Charles, MI 48655
Handouts:
If the World Were 100 People
Directions: Place the following numbers in the appropriate blanks:
| 1 |
57 |
50 |
21 |
6 |
70 |
59 |
52 |
30 |
| 1 |
80 |
70 |
1 |
48 |
8 |
6 |
1 |
14 |
If the world were 100 people there would be:
____ Asians
____ Europeans
____ North and South Americans
____ Africans
____ females
____ males
____ nonwhite, ____ white
____ percent of the entire world’s wealth would belong to only ____ people and all ____ would be citizens of the United States.
____ would live in substandard housing.
____ would be unable to read.
____ would suffer from malnutrition.
____ would be near death.
____ would be near birth.
____ would have a college education.
____ would have a computer.
“If the World Were 100 People” Answer Key
If the world were 100 people there would be:
57 Asians
21 Europeans
14 North and South Americans
8 Africans
52 females
48 males
70 nonwhite, 30 white
59 percent of the entire world’s wealth would belong to only 6 people and all 6 would be citizens of the United States
80 would live in substandard housing
70 would be unable to read
50 would suffer from malnutrition
1 would be near death
1 would be near birth
1 would have a college education
1 would have a computer
Racial Identity Autobiography and Rubric
Directions: Write a two to four paragraph autobiography based on your racial identity. Include your thoughts on these questions in any order in your autobiography.
- What is your racial identity?
- When and how did you become aware of this identity?
- What role has it played in your life?
- How does it affect you in your social activities?
- How does it affect you in your school?
- How does it affect you in your community?
- In what ways do you benefit from this identity?
- In what ways do you suffer or miss out because of this identity?
| Points |
Description |
| 4 |
To receive this score the response must:
Clearly and completely respond to all eight elements.
|
| 3 |
To receive this score the response must:
Clearly respond to six or seven elements.
|
| 2 |
To receive this score the response must:
Respond to four or five elements.
|
| 1 |
To receive this score the response must:
Respond to three or less of the elements.
|
| 0 |
Response shows no evidence of any elements or was not attempted.
|
|
The National Hate Test
| Question |
Answer |
Response |
| How important is it to you that your children have friends of other races? |
Extremely important |
|
| |
Very important |
|
| |
Somewhat important |
|
| |
Not very important |
|
| |
Not important at all |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How much would allowing a child of yours to play with another child who is HIV Positive bother you? |
Wouldn’t bother you at all |
|
| |
Bother you somewhat |
|
| |
Bother you a lot |
|
| |
Would not allow your child to play with another child who is HIV positive |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel working with someone if you knew that person was gay? |
Very comfortable |
|
| |
Fairly comfortable |
|
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
|
| |
Not very comfortable |
|
| |
Not at all comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| If you found out that a teacher in your child's school was openly gay, would you want your child taught by someone else? |
Yes |
|
| |
No |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel having a woman as your immediate boss? |
Comfortable |
|
| |
Have reservations |
|
| |
Not comfortable |
|
| |
Never feel comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel dating someone who is in a wheelchair? |
Comfortable |
|
| |
Have reservations |
|
| |
Not comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel with having an immediate family member marry someone who is of another race? |
Comfortable |
|
| |
Have reservations |
|
| |
Not comfortable |
|
| |
Never feel comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel with walking on the same side of the street as a group of teenagers? |
Comfortable |
|
| |
Have reservations |
|
| |
Not comfortable |
|
| |
Never feel comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| Who could do a better job caring for a toddler: a male baby-sitter or a female baby-sitter? |
Male baby-sitter |
|
| |
Female baby-sitter |
|
| |
Both the same |
|
| |
Depends |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel talking to someone who is obviously physically disabled? |
Very comfortable |
|
| |
Fairly comfortable |
|
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
|
| |
Not very comfortable |
|
| |
Not at all comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| Is learning a new job something younger people do better, or is it something older people do better? |
Something younger people to better |
|
| |
Something older people do better |
|
| |
They do about the same |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel examined by a physician of another race? |
Very comfortable |
|
| |
Fairly comfortable |
|
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
|
| |
Not very comfortable |
|
| |
Not at all comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How comfortable would you feel having a next-door neighbor who is of another race? |
Very comfortable |
|
| |
Fairly comfortable |
|
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
|
| |
Not very comfortable |
|
| |
Not at all comfortable |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| If your spouse or partner had been 30 pounds heavier when you first met them, would you have been as attracted to them as you actually were at that time? |
Just as attracted to them |
|
| |
Slightly less attracted to them |
|
| |
A good deal less attracted to them |
|
| |
A great deal less attracted to them |
|
| |
Not sure |
|
| How likely are you to confront a person who has made a slur against another religion? |
Extremely likely to confront that person |
|
| |
Very likely to confront that person |
|
| |
Somewhat likely to confront that person |
|
| |
Not very likely to confront that person |
|
| |
Not at all likely to confront that person |
|
| |
Not sure |
| |
www.usanetwork.com/functions/nhday/results.html
The National Hate Test Answer Key
| Question |
Answer |
Response |
| How important is it to you that your children have friends of other races? |
Extremely important |
17.5% |
| |
Very important |
19.3% |
| |
Somewhat important |
23.2% |
| |
Not very important |
11.3% |
| |
Not important at all |
15.2% |
| |
Not sure |
13.4% |
| How much would allowing a child of yours to play with another child who is HIV Positive bother you? |
Wouldn’t bother you at all |
24.7% |
| |
Bother you somewhat |
41.6% |
| |
Bother you a lot |
8.6% |
| |
Would not allow your child to play with another child who is HIV positive |
7.5% |
| |
Not sure |
17.5% |
| How comfortable would you feel working with someone if you knew that person was gay? |
Very comfortable |
40.6% |
| |
Fairly comfortable |
22.5% |
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
8.9% |
| |
Not very comfortable |
6.6% |
| |
Not at all comfortable |
9.4% |
| |
Not sure |
11.9% |
| If you found out that a teacher in your child's school was openly gay, would you want your child taught by someone else? |
Yes |
23.6% |
| |
No |
52.5% |
| |
Not sure |
23.7% |
| How comfortable would you feel having a woman as your immediate boss? |
Comfortable |
79.6% |
| |
Have reservations |
5.1% |
| |
Not comfortable |
1.6% |
| |
Never feel comfortable |
1.3% |
| |
Not sure |
12.2% |
| How comfortable would you feel dating someone who is in a wheelchair? |
Comfortable |
35.8% |
| |
Have reservations |
24.3% |
| |
Not comfortable |
10.9% |
| |
Not sure |
6.1% |
| How comfortable would you feel with having an immediate family member marry someone who is of another race? |
Comfortable |
61.0% |
| |
Have reservations |
13.4% |
| |
Not comfortable |
5.4% |
| |
Never feel comfortable |
6.2% |
| |
Not sure |
13.9% |
| How comfortable would you feel with walking on the same side of the street as a group of teenagers? |
Comfortable |
67.1% |
| |
Have reservations |
15.5% |
| |
Not comfortable |
3.5% |
| |
Never feel comfortable |
1.5% |
| |
Not sure |
12.1% |
| Who could do a better job caring for a toddler: a male baby-sitter or a female baby-sitter? |
Male baby-sitter |
1.4% |
| |
Female baby-sitter |
20.4% |
| |
Both the same |
33.0% |
| |
Depends |
32.5% |
| |
Not sure |
12.5% |
| How comfortable would you feel talking to someone who is obviously physically disabled? |
Very comfortable |
41.7% |
| |
Fairly comfortable |
32.5% |
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
8.2% |
| |
Not very comfortable |
2.8% |
| |
Not at all comfortable |
2.4% |
| |
Not sure |
12.3% |
| Is learning a new job something younger people do better, or is it something older people do better? |
Something younger people to better |
20.9% |
| |
Something older people do better |
7.8% |
| |
They do about the same |
48.6% |
| |
Not sure |
22.5% |
| How comfortable would you feel examined by a physician of another race? |
Very comfortable |
54.7% |
| |
Fairly comfortable |
19.9% |
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
5.1% |
| |
Not very comfortable |
3.1% |
| |
Not at all comfortable |
3.1% |
| |
Not sure |
13.9% |
| How comfortable would you feel having a next-door neighbor who is of another race? |
Very comfortable |
68.4% |
| |
Fairly comfortable |
12.8% |
| |
Somewhat comfortable |
3.4% |
| |
Not very comfortable |
1.5% |
| |
Not at all comfortable |
2.0% |
| |
Not sure |
11.8% |
| If your spouse or partner had been 30 pounds heavier when you first met them, would you have been as attracted to them as you actually were at that time? |
Just as attracted to them |
37.4% |
| |
Slightly less attracted to them |
22.2% |
| |
A good deal less attracted to them |
9.2% |
| |
A great deal less attracted to them |
7.3% |
| |
Not sure |
23.7% |
| How likely are you to confront a person who has made a slur against another religion? |
Extremely likely to confront that person |
16.8% |
| |
Very likely to confront that person |
19.3% |
| |
Somewhat likely to confront that person |
22.0% |
| |
Not very likely to confront that person |
15.0% |
| |
Not at all likely to confront that person |
9.0% |
| |
Not sure |
17.8% | |
The National Hate Test Special
www.usanetwork.com/functions/nhday/results.html
STAND AND DELIVER
Directions: Ask participants to seat themselves in a circle, in chairs or on the floor, so that they can see everyone. The moderator should stand or sit in the circle. Explain that statements will be read that indicate the complexity of diversity and experience. Ask that as each statement is read, those who identify with that statement should stand. Allow time for participants to observe and encourage them to consider the following:
- who is standing or sitting with you,
- how you are feeling.
Next, thank participants and ask them to be seated again and read another statement. The entire activity should be done in total silence until the debriefing segment.
“Stand and deliver if you identify as being/having…”
- A male?
- A female?
- Born in the U.S.?
- Born in another country?
- An only child?
- The youngest child?
- The oldest child?
- The middle child?
- Lived away from home?
- African-American?
- Hispanic?
- Arab American?
- Native-American?
- Asian-American/Pacific Islander?
- Middle Eastern?
- Associated with an ethnic group that was not mentioned previously?
- Been raised in a lower-income family?
- Been raised in an upper-income family?
- Been raised in a middle-income family?
- Able to speak a language other than English?
- Spiritual, but not religious?
- Spiritual?
- Having seriously questioned your religious beliefs?
- Having been teased about your accent or your voice, or told that you could not sing?
- Having a family member or a friend who has a disability that you can or cannot see?
- Been raised in a single-parent household?
Stand and Deliver
- Been raised in a household with extended family, such as aunts, uncles and/or grandparents)?
- Having parents who have been divorced from one another?
- Having parents who have been married only to each other for 20 years or more?
- Having had a close family member/friend die?
- Having both parents still living?
- Having felt alone, unwelcome or afraid at some time in your life?
- Having been teased or made fun of for wearing glasses, braces, a hearing aid or because of the clothes you wear, your height, weight, complexion, or size or shape of your body?
- Having felt pressure from friends or an adult to do something that you did not want to do and felt sorry or shame afterwards?
- Having been discriminated against because of your age?
- Having been discriminated against because of your gender?
- Having been discriminated against because of your race?
- Having broken a law and gotten caught?
- Having broken a law and not gotten caught?
- Having stood by and watched while someone was emotionally or physically hurt and said or did nothing because you were too afraid?
- Planning to speak out and do something from now on when you see someone being pressured to do something that they do not want to do?
- Feeling that one person can make a difference?
- Finally, stand and deliver if you feel that tolerance of diversity is a must if we are to survive as a global community?
Healing Racism Action Plan
Today we focused on increasing your awareness of racism issues. The next step is to make plans so that you can apply your new knowledge to different aspects of your life. Take a few minutes to think about what action steps can be taken and then complete the following statements:
In my personal life I can _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
At my school I can _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
In my community, I can _________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________