Lesson 2: Being a Prophet—Traits of the Trade
Handout 1

A True Prophet Versus a False Prophet (Parochial School Version)

(parochial school version from Written On Our Hearts)

 

A True Prophet

A False Prophet

  • usually is reluctant to speak for God
  • eagerly takes on the job of speaking for God
  • listens to the authentic voice of God within him or her and then communicates God’s thoughts
  • listens to his or her own opinions and wishes, communicating those as God’s thoughts
  • tells people the truth, even if it hurts
  • says what people want to hear
  • is a realist
  • is an optimist
  • conveys a message that is consistent with the faith of Israel, the Sinai covenant
  • conveys a message that is consistent with most people’s inclinations
  • is unpopular, holds no official position, and suffers for telling the truth
  • is popular, often holds an official position, and leads a comfortable lifestyle
  • offers people hope and a means of surviving suffering and devastation
  • offers people no way to make sense of suffering and loss
  • lives the message preached
  • talks a lot without taking action
  • has a message that stands the test of time
  • has a message that does not hold up over time; it is not confirmed by historical development