Learning to Give, Curriculum Division of The LEAGUE

The LEAGUE

Hurricane Katrina Relief - Power, Generosity and Leadership!
(Written as a 6-12 unit. Adapt as appropriate for 9-12.)
Lesson 1:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Purpose:

Learners will research problems caused by Hurricane Katrina and cite examples of aid provided in an effort to help those devastated populations. They will investigate the role of the four economic sectors in responding to the needs. They will participate in a collection campaign and learn about organizations to which they can contribute their philanthropy.

Duration:

Length of the Project Dependent on Teacher Preference

Objectives:

The learner will:

  • define philanthropy and its relationship to the four economic sectors.
  • research philanthropic organizations involved in Hurricane Katina relief effort.
  • organize and carry out a collection drive and contribute to a nonprofit organization(s).
  • reflect on their effort and its results.

 

Service Experience:

Although this lesson contains a service project example, decisions about service plans and implementation should be made by students, as age appropriate.

The learners will collect money or items for hurricane relief. They will choose a relief organization(s) to contribute to and advocate for aid in their families, school and community peer groups.

Materials:

  • Attachment One: Sector Information for Discussion for teacher information or optional copies for students
  • Learner copies of Attachment Two: White House Press Release
  • Learner copies of Reflection Rubric (see Attachment Three)
  • Learner copies of Conducting Research (see Attachment Five)
  • Optional Extension: Web of Concern Sample (see Attachment Four)
Handout 1
Sector Information for Discussion
Handout 2
White House Press Release
Handout 3
Reflection Rubric
Handout 4
Web of Concern Sample
Handout 5
Conducting Research
Handout 6
Hurrican Katrina Relief Organizations

Instructional Procedure(s):

Teacher Note: This lesson has two options for the Anticipatory Set. Choose the option that will work the best for the teaching/learning styles of you and your students.

Anticipatory Set, Option One:

Before students arrive, push all the desk/tables to the back of the room so that you have a large open space. Write on the board or overhead "Take out a pencil and paper and write about being homeless."

As students walk into the room, give them a card/paper that states:

Your desk is your home in this classroom and it’s no longer available to you. In addition, you must give up your worldly possessions (backpacks, paper, pencil, etc.) by putting them on the back desks/tables. Please look to the overhead (or board) for further instruction.

It will become obvious to your students that they cannot do this and, by now, your room is utterly chaotic! Some will sit on the floor; others will complain; some will refuse to do anything. This is expected. Play the role. Be stern about expecting them to do the assignment. Allow a few minutes to pass in order to get reactions from students.

Ask the students to be seated on the floor and process the activity by asking:

  • How did you feel about giving up your possessions?

  • How did you feel when you could not complete the assignment and had nothing with which to work?

  • How would you feel if you lost everything in a natural disaster? (Discuss exactly what would be lost..., pictures, clothes, mementos, and other valuables, possibly even family members and friends).

  • How would you feel if you had no place to live?

  • Who would be there to help you?

Review the four sectors of the U.S. economy: For-profit, Nonprofit, Government and Household (See Attachment One: Sector Information for Discussion as resource information.

Teacher Note:

At this point, you may choose to have the students return to their seats or continue the lesson with the students sitting on the floor.

If Anticipatory Set, Option One was chosen, skip Anticipatory Set, Option Two and continue the lesson with the first bullet of the Instructional Procedure

Anticipatory Set, Option Two:

Instruct the learners to create a list of all of the places they (or their family) have been in the last week. Allow a few minutes for students to individually brainstorm this list.

Create a chart with four columns as a class display. The labels are to be left off the chart until the end of this portion of the activity. Choose a recorder to write the name of the places visited on the chart as they are directed. The teacher will direct the recorder to write answers in the appropriate column as they are volunteered. Learners are then asked to share two of the places, from the list they have generated during the anticipatory set. The teacher will direct the recorder to write the name of the place in the first column each time a government location is mentioned, the second column each time a for-profit business is given, and the third column each time a nonprofit is suggested. Once the lists have been created, ask the students to come up with some ideas as to why the places were classified into these three different groups. The teacher will then put the name of the category on the appropriate column of the chart. Note: If students do not include enough locations or places for any of the columns, then the teacher should feel free to provide examples of their own to balance the chart.

Discuss the similarities/difference between for-profit, nonprofit, and government sectors. Use Attachment One: Sector Information for Discussion as a discussion guide. Tell the students that the three sectors work together to supply goods and services and to meet needs and wants. Many types of organizations/businesses may exist in more than one sectors. As an example, public school may be nonprofit while a charter or private school may be for-profit or nonprofit. More obvious examples of different sectors could be given using General Motors as a for-profit organization and the Red Cross as a non-profit.

Ask the students what they think the fourth sector (the fourth column) may be. If no one volunteers a correct response, tell them it represents the Household Sector. Households supply goods and services to meet wants and needs just like the other three sectors. Write household at the top of the third column. Use child-care as an example of how the four sectors work. There are for profit childcare centers, the government my run a tax supported childcare center, a nonprofit, such as a faith based organization may offer childcare and family members (such as grandparents) may supply childcare.

  • Display the word philanthropy and define it for the students as: sharing time, talent and treasure, and taking action for the common good. Tell the students that the nonprofit sector is also known as the philanthropic sector.

  • Tell the students that it will take all four of these economic sectors working together to respond to the disaster in the Gulf Coast region caused by Hurricane Katrina. Former Presidents Bush and Clinton have been asked by President G.W. Bush to lead a joint effort to raise private donations for victims of Hurricane Katrina.

  • Distribute student copies of Attachment Two. Read the excerpt for the White House Press Release. Ask the students how the president’s request for Americans "to open their hearts and their wallets to help those in need" relates to the definition of philanthropy.

  • Ask the learners how they could mobilize the power, generosity, and leadership of young people in their class/school/community to respond to the hurricane disaster. Discuss what steps would be necessary to ensure participation by the entire class, school or community. Create a series of posters and/or a theme song/rap that would attract the attention of as many potential philanthropists as possible. Write a letter for the school paper or tape an interview for the local cable station on the hurricane disaster and the efforts of the relief agency your school decides to support. Discuss if a school group such as the Student Council should take major responsibility for organizing the drive. Should there be a challenge goal?

  • Plan, organize and begin the collection drive.

    Teacher Note: If computer research by students is not possible, in advance the teacher can print information from several of the organizations suggested that might be appropriate for their local school to support with contributions. Information about a different organization could be distributed to each research group so they can complete Attachment Five: Conducting Research.

  • As the drive progresses, form the learners into small research groups and have groups research organizations listed in Attachment Six that would be appropriate for the students/school to donate to. The teacher can select a few of the organizations appropriate for the school/students or the students can be allowed to select an organization. Access the Federal Emergency Management (FEMA) Web site: www.FEMA.gov, Bush-Clinton Katrina Fund: http://www.bushclintonkatrinafund.org/ and/or the National Voluntary Organizations Active in Disaster web site: http://www.nvoad.org/membersdb.php?members=National or distribute the list of relief organizations found in Attachment Six.

  • After the research is complete have the groups report their findings and recommend whether or not they think this would be an appropriate organization to donate funds to. Vote or come to consensus about which organization(s) will receive the funds.

    Teacher Note: Student voice is very important in making the decision of where to donate funds. The choice of organization can be made by voting or by consensus. The learners may decide on one organization to receive the donations, or to give a percentage of the donations to several organizations. Follow up on the work of the organization in the hurricane area by periodically researching their accomplishments and problems as they work to reinvigorate the area.

    Reflection:

  • After the collection drive is complete, have the learners reflect on the issues that have been brought to their attention as a result of the hurricane disaster. Distribute Reflection Rubric (Attachment Two). Ask the learners to write an essay/poem/song that encompasses the ideas of personal involvement for the common good. Include the accomplishments of the collection, how the learner felt acting as a philanthropist for this worthy cause, lessons learned during completion of the task, and the outcomes of the experience. Consider what would be the consequences of a world in which there were no private philanthropic efforts made by its citizens? Consider the importance of philanthropy, not only in this particular situation, but also in one’s nation, state, city, school and neighborhood. Will this experience happen once or will it encourage a continued role of personal involvement for the sake of others?

    OR

  • In a journal activity, have the learners reflect on the way they saw the world before the tragedy of the hurricane and what they have learned about people as a result of the devastation. Think about the famous words from John Donne’s Meditation XVII:

    No man is an island, entire of itself...any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind; and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.

    In the journal response, ask students to agree or disagree with the quote based on their experience with Hurricane Katrina relief.

Extension:

  • Philanthropy and the Economic Sectors

Form the class into small groups. Give each group one of the following areas of concern: education, business/economics, government, housing, health, family, psychological and social concerns. All of these aspects of life were affected in some way by the hurricane problems. Explain that each problem listed could cause major havoc in the lives of the people of the Gulf Region. All the problems will have to be addressed, not only in the short-term, but for a long time after the relief effort begins. Have each group draw a web or map around each term, brainstorming a list of its problems related to the hurricane devastation. (See Web of Concern Sample Attachment Four.) Use the Internet if available. Have the groups report on the problems identified in their area of concern.

Once the problems have been identified, they must all be addressed. Explain that no one government or organization can possibly handle all of these problems. As a result it is important for all four sectors of the economy, including government, for profit businesses, nonprofit organizations, and the household, to come to the aid of the people devastated by the hurricane.

Discuss why it is important to have an active nonprofit sector instead of having the government responsible for handling all areas of concern. Ask the learners for examples of nonprofit organizations that are important in this effort. Is there a role for families in this tragedy? Think back to the devastating events of the tsunami and September 11, 2001. What groups and individuals came to the aid of those involved? From what sectors of the economy did help come?

  • Philanthropy and Geography

Go online to research which countries have suffered weather-related problems in the past. Are there any international service or religious groups that came to their aid, or are presently involved in those countries with specific programs of aid?

Research other countries that have been devastated in some way (through war, an environmental problem, or weather) and describe how they have been able to recoup (if they did). Are there any international service or religious groups that came to their aid or are presently involved in those countries with specific programs of aid?

Bibliographical References:

Lesson Developed and Piloted by:

Evelyn Nash
Curriculum Consultant
Learning to Give

Barbara Dillbeck
Curriculum Director
Learning to Give

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Sector Information for Discussion

For-Profit Sector

Government

Nonprofit Sector

Exists to make a profit.

Exists to provide public goods and services that meet the needs or expectations of the majority such as the postal service and national defense.

Exists to meet needs that for profit and government cannot or do not, and to represent the minority. Often the catalyst for social change.

Provide goods or services related to demand and profit.

Can regulate what the for-profit world does, for example, telephone service.

May provide goods and services related to need.

Payment is dependent on the choice to purchase the good or service.

They have coercive power. They can tax you or make you purchase a license.

They are concerned about client satisfaction.

Profit is distributed to the owners or share-holders of the business for their own private use.

They may promise to provide services in order to win elections.

Profit does not benefit any individuals connected with the organization. It is invested in furthering the mission of the organization.

 

Handout 2Print Handout 2

White House Press Release

President Asks Bush and Clinton to Assist in Hurricane Relief Efforts

The Oval Office
September 1, 2005

(Excerpt)

This recovery is going to be a long process. It's going to take a lot of hard work and patience and resolve. It's also going to require a lot of money. And the federal government will do its part. But the private sector needs to do its part, as well. And that's why I've asked Presidents Bush and Clinton to lead a nationwide fundraising effort to help the victims of Hurricane Katrina.

In the days ahead, the former Presidents will ask Americans to open their hearts and their wallets to help those in need. And they're going to talk to large corporations and small businesses and individual citizens across the nation. The contributions will benefit the relief organizations that are doing vital work on the ground. We're going to take a look and make sure that the money raised is money needed. Right now if our fellow citizens want to help, they ought to give a cash donation to the Red Cross, which they can find at phone number 1-800-HELP-NOW.

I was so proud of the efforts that President Clinton and President Bush did to help the victims of the tsunami relief. Our country marveled at their capacity to rally our citizens and to work together. And, once again, I’ve asked them to work to help the needs of those who hurt. And, once again, I’m confident that the American people will respond.

Excerpt from a Press release by the Office of the Press Secretary

Accessed from http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/09/20050901-3.html September 7, 2005.

Handout 3Print Handout 3

Reflection Rubric

 

In order to receive:

The following criteria must be met:

5

  • The reflective piece stresses the idea of personal involvement for the common good.

It includes:

  • the accomplishments of the drive;
  • discusses how the learner felt acting as a philanthropist for this cause;
  • points out lessons learned during the completion of the task;
  • and assesses outcomes of the experience.
  • It considers what the world would be like without private philanthropic efforts.
  • It describes the importance of philanthropy in one’s own environment.
  • The piece concludes with a commitment to continued personal involvement for the sake of others.

4

The reflective piece includes six or seven of the criteria.

3

The reflective piece includes four or five of the criteria.

2

The reflective piece includes two or three of the criteria.

1

The reflective piece includes only one of the criteria.

0

None of the criteria were met.

of the criteria were met.

Handout 4Print Handout 4

Web of Concern Sample

Directions: Put one of the following areas of concern in the center of the circle and put problems related to that area in each box. Feel free to branch out from each box with additional implications if necessary. Do this for each area.

education, business/economics, government,
housing, health, family, psychological, social

Handout 5Print Handout 5

Conducting Research

To investigate each relief organization, fill in its purpose or mission statement, objectives and accomplishments.

Name of Organization: _______________________________________

Purpose or Mission Statement

 

 

 

 

 

 

Objectives

 

 

 

 

 

 

Accomplishments

 

 

 

 

 

 

Handout 6Print Handout 6

Hurrican Katrina Relief Organizations

Bush-Clinton Katrina Fund: http://www.bushclintonkatrinafund.org/

FEMA'S SUGGESTED RELIEF ORGANIZATIONS

Note: 800 and 888 phone numbers work only in the U.S. and Canada

American Red Cross
http://www.redcross.org/
English: 800 HELP NOW (435 7669)
Spanish: 800 257 7575

Operation Blessing
http://www.ob.org/programs/disaster_relief/news/2005/dr_2005_0824_katrina.asp
800 436 6348

America's Second Harvest
http://www.secondharvest.org/
800 344 8070

Adventist Community Services
http://www.communityservices.org/SiteResources/Data/Templates/templatea.asp?docid=514&DocName=Home
800 381 7171

Catholic Charities USA
http://www.catholiccharitiesusa.org/news/katrina.cfm
+1 703 549 1390

Christian Disaster Response
http://www.cdresponse.org/
1 941 956 5183 or +1 941 551 9554

Christian Reformed World Relief Committee
http://www.crwrc.org/
800 848 5818

Church World Service
http://www.churchworldservice.org/news/archives/2005/08/317.html
800 297 1516

Convoy of Hope
http://www.convoyofhope.org/
+1 417 823 8998

Lutheran Disaster Response
http://www.ldr.org/index.html
800 638 3522

Mennonite Disaster Service
http://www.mds.mennonite.net/
+1 717 859 2210

Nazarene Disaster Response
http://www.nazarenedisasterresponse.org/katrina.html
888 256 5886

Presbyterian Disaster Assistance
http://www.pcusa.org/pda/response/usa/hurricanekatrina-index.htm
800 872 3283

Salvation Army
http://www.salvationarmyusa.org/
800 SAL ARMY (725 2769)

Southern Baptist Convention—Disaster Relief
http://www.namb.net/site/c.9qKILUOzEpH/b.224451/k.7BDB/Disaster_Relief_Homepage.htm
800 462 8657, ext. 6440

United Methodist Committee on Relief
http://gbgm-umc.org/umcor/05/katrinaresp.cfm
800 554 8583

Source: www.FEMA.gov accessed 9-1-05


Or access the list of organizations found at the National Voluntary Organizations Active in Disaster web site: http://www.nvoad.org/membersdb.php?members=National.

Philanthropy Framework:

Submit a Comment

Unit Contents:

Overview:Hurricane Katrina Relief - Power, Generosity and Leadership!
(Written as a 6-12 unit. Adapt as appropriate for 9-12.)
Summary

Lessons:

1.
Hurricane Katrina Relief - Power, Generosity and Leadership!
(Written as a 6-12 unit. Adapt as appropriate for 9-12.)

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.

Copyright © LearningToGive.org