3rd-5th Grade
Subjects:
Language Arts, Library / Technology, Philanthropy and Social Studies
Key Words/Concepts click to view
| ELA: | Compare/Contrast; Fable; Genre; Group Discussions; Literary Response; Parable; Perception |
| PHIL: | Caring/Sharing; Giving; LEAGUE Event Lesson: One Day; Respect; Responsibility; Selflessness; Time/Talent/Treasure |
| SOC: | Common Good; Communities; Core Democratic Values; Wants/Needs |
Focus Question(s):
What does it mean to be a member of a community?
NOTE: Prior to this lesson, use the Blue Sky Activity in which students envision a better world. If you already have a Blue Sky display, revisit it before beginning this lesson.
Purpose:
This lesson will expose learners to philanthropy in three different genres of literature: a play, a fable, and a parable. Through the genres the students will learn about community, helping others by addressing a need and philanthropic acts.
Duration:
One Forty-Five Minute Class Period
Objectives:
The learner will:
- analyze what comprises a community.
- identify philanthropic acts.
- compare and contrast these acts in three different situations.
- take a stand and defend his/her viewpoint on who can perform a needed service for the community.
Instructional Procedure(s):
Anticipatory Set:
Explain to the class that they will be studying three different pieces of literature that were written or told in different times and places. Explain that each piece of literature represents a different “genre.” Ask the learners from what language they think the word “genre” comes. (French) Tell the students that even though there will be three stories, the stories will have a theme, moral or lesson in common that can be compared and contrasted.
- Tell the students that you will be reading them three short stories. Post the comparison chart in Attachment Four, “Comparing the Stories,” and tell the students that for each of the stories they will be listening for the answers to these same questions and comparing the stories. Read the questions with the students.
- Beginning with Aesop’s fable “The Lion and the Mouse,” answer the questions on the chart. Possible Question Responses:
- What is the need?( Freedom from captivity)
- Who has the need? (The lion)
- Who is in the community?( The whole jungle)
- Who fills the need?( The mouse)
- What talent or treasure was given? ( The mouse used his talent of gnawing to help the lion)
- What did it cost to give? ( The mouse risked having the hunters come back before he was done)
- What benefit does the community experience from that giving or sharing? (The lion received freedom because of the mouse.)
- What is the reward for the one or ones who shared? (The mouse and the lion became unlikely friends.)
- What would have happened if the need had not been met? (The lion would be taken captive for the rest of his life.)
- Follow the same steps for The Good San Franciscan (Attachment One) and Someone Should (Attachment Two).
The Good San Franciscan
Possible responses are:
- What is the need? (The need was medical aid.)
- Who has the need? (Roger Walters had the need.)
- Who is in the community? (The whole population of San Francisco, especially those driving along the freeway, was in the community.)
- Who fills the need? (Julio Sanchez)
- What talent or treasure was given? (Julio shared time, effort, and twenty dollars.)
- What did it cost to give? (Julio’s time, which made him get home later after a long day, and money of which he had little.)
- What benefit does the community experience from that giving or sharing? (The whole community experienced a healing because of what Julio’s did.)
- What is the reward for the one or ones who shared? (Julio’s was rewarded by knowing he did the right thing.)
- What would have happened if the need had not been met? (If Julio’s hadn’t stopped to help, Mr. Walters might not have recovered from the robbery and beating.)
Someone Should
Possible question responses:
- What is the need? (The hall was a big mess and needed cleaning up.)
- Who has the need? ( The whole school had the need to have a clean building)
- Who is in the community? (The community included the teachers, administrators and students.)
- Who fills the need? (The kindergartner filled the need.)
- What talent or treasure was given? (The talent of picking up the mess was shared by the kindergartner.)
- What did it cost to give? (It cost time and effort.)
- What benefit does the community experience from that giving or sharing? (The community had a nice clean and tidy hallway.)
- What is the reward for the one or ones who shared? (The kindergartner just felt good that he/she did the right thing.)
- What would have happened if the need had not been met? (The hall would have gotten messier.)
- Once learners have completed the exercise for each piece of literature, ask them if there were any comparisons or contrasts that could be made. The learners should come to realize that in each piece of literature one character made a difference by practicing philanthropy. Have the learners describe the character who gave of their time, talent or treasure in each of the readings. The one character in each of the readings who acted philanthropically was small, meek, and not so powerful.
LEAGUE Learning Link(s): (click to view)
Have an idea for a Learning Link?
If your Link is accepted for publication on the Web site you will be credited with your name, school, and city.
These "LEAGUE Learning Links” provide ten quick and easy 5-minute mini-lessons to help promote The LEAGUE’s vision and scheduled events in your classroom. You can choose from among these mini-lessons and use as many of them as you would like and in whatever order best meets your needs and the interest of your students. The purpose of these mini-lessons is to provide a deeper understanding of philanthropy (the giving of ones, time, talents, and treasures for the common good) and to promote those philanthropic acts that have been identified as supporting The LEAGUE events. These mini-lessons will also help ensure a deeper understanding of character traits, civic engagement, and promote student leadership. It is recommended that students be encouraged to play as much of a role as possible and appropriate in presenting these lessons to their classmates.
- Read: There is a famous song. Its title is "Dry Bones" or "Dem Dry Bones." This song has been used as a way to teach the parts of the skeleton. Two brothers wrote the tune and the words. James Wedlon Johnson wrote the tune and J. Rosamund Johnson wrote the words. The words go something like this
….Your toe bone connected to your foot bone, Your foot bone connected to your ankle bone, Your ankle bone connected to your leg bone, Your leg bone connected to your knee bone, Your knee bone connected to your thigh bone, Your thigh bone connected to your hip bone, Your hip bone connected to your back bone, Your back bone connected to your shoulder bone, Your shoulder bone connected to your neck bone Your neck bone connected to your head bone…. Etc.
Discuss: Why is it important that all our bones be connected? What would happen if they were not connected? Why is it important that we all work together on our One Day event? What might happen if we do not work together?
- Read: Everyone in Mr. Axion’s class laughed as we watched the zoo keeper try to put a live octopus back into its box. It seemed that whenever he got one of its arms in the box another one popped out. The zoo keeper told the class that the octopus uses its eight arms to do many things besides crawling out of boxes. He said that the octopus makes good use of its arms. It uses them to play as well as to get food. They help the octopus move around. They also are used to help take care of its young. Then he told us something very interesting. He said that an octopus has three hearts! When the zoo keeper left to go back to the zoo with his animals, Mr. Axion asked the class some questions.
Discuss: Let’s pretend for a minute that we are in Mr. Axion’s class. How would you answer the following questions Mr. Axion asked his students: “If we had eight arms to use during our One Day event, what do you think would happen?” “How do you think life would be different if we all had three hearts instead of just one?” “How can we make the best use of our one heart and two arms during our One Day event?”
- Read: McGruff the Crime Dog tells us to “help take a bite out of crime.” If your TV could talk to you it would probably tell you that it wants to “help take a bite out time.” Your time. We all know that watching too much TV can take a big bite out of our time. It can rob us of time together with our family. It can cut into our meal and exercise-times. It can swallow up our playtime. Sometimes it gets in the way of our doing our school work and other things that we are supposed to be doing. People who study our TV watching habits say that most young people in the US will spend more time in front of the television (1,023 hours) than in their school each year (900 hours). We need to remember that there are many more important things to do than just watching TV. Seventy (70) national organizations support TV-Turnoff Week. During this week everyone is asked to reduce their TV watching. Turning off the television gives everyone an opportunity to think, read, create, and do. It gives people a chance to re-connect with their families. It gives people a chance to greet their neighbors. A good TV-Turnoff Week motto is: Turn off your TV and turn on your life.
Discuss: Can you think of things we could do if we didn’t watch so much TV? In what ways might reducing our TV watching help us accomplish our goal for our One Day event? In what ways might we be able to re-connect with our families and our communities during our One Day event? Mottos say things in very short phrases or sentences. What might be a good motto for our One Day event?
- Read: I’m sure that everyone knows what a little ladybug looks like. But do you know that at one time people used to ask the ladybug for good weather. In parts of the world children were even told that human babies were brought by ladybugs. Some people counted the spots on the backs of ladybugs. If they had fewer than seven spots it meant a big harvest in the fall. Some believed that if a young woman caught a ladybug in her hand and it crawled across her hand that she would be married within a year. Years ago, doctors believed that ladybugs could be used to treat measles. Ladybugs as tiny and as cute as they are, are very useful. They are especially well liked by gardeners because ladybugs love to eat bugs that damage plants.
Discuss: Sometimes people think that because we are little we can’t do much. To them we’re just cute. How could what we do during our One Day event help show people that like the ladybug we may be cute but we are also very useful?
- Read: Cooperation means working together to do something instead of working separately or in competition. To be successful, most projects require everyone to cooperate. Here are nine ways we can show cooperation. We can listen carefully to others. That way we can be sure we understand what they are saying. We can share when we have something that others would like to have. We can take turns when there is something that nobody wants to do or when more than one person wants to do the same thing. We can compromise when we have a serious disagreement over something. We can find ways to agree. That way everyone feels better about the decision. We can each do our part. That way we know the job will get done. We can show our appreciation to others for their help by thanking them. We can encourage everyone to do their best. We can help make people feel needed. Working together is a lot more fun than working alone. We need to be sure that we don’t isolate or exclude anyone. Everybody has something valuable to offer. Nobody likes being left out.
Discuss: Why is it important for us to cooperate during our One Day event? Of these nine ways that we can show cooperation, what do you think might be the hardest thing to do? Why do you think so? How can we make it easier?
www.goodcharacter.com/YCC/Cooperation.html
- Read: Most athletes only dream the athletes’ dream. It’s the dream of scoring the winning basket with time running out on the clock. It’s the dream of driving in the winning run in the bottom of the ninth with two outs and the bases loaded. It’s the dream of scoring the go-ahead goal at the buzzer. It’s the dream of acing the final serve to win the tennis match. The dream of kicking the soccer ball father than anyone. Occasionally, these dreams do become a reality for some. But it does not happen often and usually not always to the same athlete. That’s because in most sports, winning is a team effort rather than an individual effort. The slogan, There is no ‘I’ in team! encourages individuals to play as a team and not for individual glory. To be a team everyone needs to be working together doing what needs to be done. In that way everyone has a chance to be a part of the athletes’ dream.
Discuss: What might be some of our dreams for our One Day event? In what ways does our One Day event need to be a team effort? What do we need to do in order to experience and celebrate the thrill of our team’s accomplishment on this day?
- Read: There have been many times in our history when people have said “it couldn’t be done”. Or they said it was "crazy to even try". Only later were they proved wrong. Examples: “People can’t fly in heavier than air machines, that ridiculous. “People will never be able to talk to each other over tiny wires (or through the air)”. “There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home”. “Be a recording company for the Beatles? No way! We don't like their sound, and guitar music is on the way out."
Discuss: Do you think there are people who are saying that what we have planned for our One Day event can’t be done? How can we avoid feeling crazy and ridiculous for even trying to accomplish the things we set out to do for our One Day event? How might our accomplishments during our One Day event be of encouragement to others to try the “weirdly impossible”?
- Read: We can learn a lot about life by watching the eagle. Parents of young eagles (eaglets) watch over them very attentively until they have grown all their feathers. The parents then “stir up the nest”. This means that they make things less comfortable in the nest. They toss out all the soft nesting material. Then they force the young eagles to stand on their own feet in order to strengthen their muscles and talons getting them ready for eagle life. When young eaglets are old enough to fly, they do not realize they are able to fly. In fact they are still terrified of falling out of the nest. They like being where they are and having someone take care of them. We could say that they are in their “comfort zone”. The eaglets have spent their whole lives trying their best not to fall out of the nest. While other birds coax their young out of the nest with food, this is not true for eagles. When the day comes that the parents decide it’s time, they push the young eaglets out of the nest for their own good. The mama eagle physically pushes them out of the nest while the daddy eagle circles nearby waiting to catch them if they are so afraid that they forget to open their wings and start gliding. The good news is if they don’t glide quickly, daddy eagle will gently catch them before they hit the ground and return them to the nest. The bad news is, in a few more days the mama eagle has to push them out of the nest again until they finally learn to fly. To survive, young eaglets eventually need to become eagles in their own right.
Discuss: We all experience fear at some time or another. We may be afraid that we can’t do it; that we won’t measure up; that others might not like us; that we aren’t good enough. What might be some of the “comfort zones” that kids don’t want to leave during our One Day event? How can we gently push them out of their “comfort zone” so they won’t be afraid to “soar with us” during our One Day event? What assurance can we give them that we will “catch them” should they become afraid? How might our involvement in our One Day event help us become responsible people?
- Read:
For want of a nail the shoe was lost.
For want of a shoe the horse was lost.
For want of a horse the rider was lost.
For want of a rider the battle was lost.
For want of a battle the kingdom was lost.
And all for the want of a horseshoe nail.
This rhyme talks about horses, riders, kingdoms, and battles so it probably was written a long time ago in England. Much later, Benjamin Franklin put a version of this rhyme in his book entitled, Poor Richard's Almanac. Still later, during World War II, this rhyme was framed and hung on the wall of a supply headquarters. Often it is used to remind people of the importance of little things. All actions, big or small, have consequences. What may seem unimportant can have a major impact on how things turn out. Today, this rhyme is often used to encourage people to make an effort, even if that effort appears not to be important. Who knows? Maybe it will be very important!
Discuss: How might we use this rhyme to promote student involvement in our One Day event? How might we use this rhyme to encourage those who feel they have nothing to offer? How could we help them to see that their effort could be very significant?
www.rhymes.org.uk/for_want_of_a_nail.htm
- Read: Two men looked out from prison bars.
One saw mud, one saw stars.
Most athletes will tell you that their biggest challenge often is not the physical challenge but the mental one. One athlete put it this way, “I have to visualize myself doing what I need to do. If I can’t do that I am won’t reach my potential. It’s known as the principle of vision, to see that the best is available to you and to be convinced that it’s possible for you to attain it.”
Discuss: As we think about our planned One Day event(s) what “vision” comes to your mind? Why is important that we believe that what we are attempting to accomplish is possible? What are some things we could do mentally during our One Day event to stay focused on the “stars” How can we be of encouragement to someone who is looking only at the “mud”?
Extension:
Do a reader’s theater with this script of Attachment Three “Someone Should,” having students read the different parts. After they feel comfortable with their parts, the students might want to perform the script for a younger class. At the end of the performance, performers and audience participants may pair up and talk about how this school episode showed philanthropy at work. Students can realize that by performing this little play and instructing the younger students they have practiced philanthropy as well.
Post Service Reflection: (click to view)
Reflection plays a very important role in promoting student learning. The following suggested activities are ways to help students reflect on their learning after they have participated in a service event. Choose one or more of the activities most appropriate to the service event and your students.
ACTIVITY ONE: Have each student write a paragraph about his or her personal LEAGUE Event experience using one of these prompt analogies:
This LEAGUE Event was:
Like baking a cake, because…
Like hugging a friend, because…a
Like reading a good book, because…
Like running a race, because
Like planting a flower, because
ACTIVITY TWO: Holding one end of the yarn, toss the yarn ball to a student and have that student use one word or phrase, describe/summarize his or her personal LEAGUE Event experience. After the student has responded, have that student hold the end of the yarn and toss the yarn ball to another student--continuing to unravel the yarn ball-- repeating the process until everyone is part of the web created by the yarn. Passing is permissible. (Note: Point out to the students that the web represents the interconnectedness of people and their experiences.) If time permits, have the students “retrace” the yarn ball tosses. This time the student with the yarn ball rewinds the yarn onto the ball while sharing what he or she feels might be the effects of the event or what more they would like to do before tossing it back to the student who originally tossed it to him/her. Continue this process until the yarn ball is back in your hands.
ACTIVITY THREE: Collect a bag of inexpensive small toys. (These could be borrowed from a Kindergarten classroom.) Place these toys in a large brown bag. Assign students to groups of four or five. Have a member of each group select from the bag, without looking at any of the toys. Have each group explain to the other groups how this toy might represent what they did, how they felt, or suggest in some way what impact they might have had as a result of the event project. Allow the groups time to meet and brainstorm together for a few minutes before making their presentation.
ACTIVITY FOUR: Have the class determine how much money they “saved” others by offering their volunteer service(s) or donations during this Event. To calculate the volunteer services amount, have each student identify the number of hours they were involved in the activity and multiply this number by the minimum wage for your State. (The Federal minimum wage can also be used which is approximately $7.00 per hour.) To calculate the donations amount, have the students count the total amount of money raised during the fundraiser. Celebrate the grand total savings to others that the students have provided during this Event.
Bibliographical References:
A copy of Aesop's Fable, The Lion and the Mouse
http://www.pagebypagebooks.com/
Aesop/Aesops_Fables/The_Lion_and_the_Mouse_p1.html
Lesson Developed and Piloted by:
Kim Davison
Kalamazoo Public Schools
Woods Lake Elementary School
Kalamazoo, MI 49008
Handouts:
The Good San Franciscan
Roger Walters drove his BMW confidently down the expressway. He had made that sale, and all was well with the world. He picked up his cellular phone to call his wife and tell her he would be home in less than an hour. What a day it had been! Success was pulsing in his veins.
Flash! A bullet came from nowhere, grazed the side of his head and pierced through the windshield. Roger somehow swerved to the side and came to a stop. All that happened next was awful and tragic. Roger Walters was left unconscious, robbed, and alone.
Marie Grace was driving to her meeting shortly after the crime. She saw the slumped shape and strangely parked car. Thinking she better not be late, she headed for the left lane to avoid the whole mishap. She turned her head so that she wouldn’t see what it was. Soon the whole scene was out of her mind.
Mr. Smith and his aide were traveling down this same thoroughfare. They were reviewing the findings of the day. Much data was yet to be processed. When would they find the time to do all that needed to be done? Each noticed the car at the same time.
The aide suggested the best thing to do was to call the state trooper’s post and get help. After trying several times to get through, they decided someone would stop, and that it was not necessary for them to stop themselves. The weight of their duty made them press on.
Julio’s Sanchez said “good night” to Lon Nguyen who took over his shift for the night. He was so very tired from being on his feet most of the eight hours of his workday as a security guard at the plant. He looked forward to going home and having that great meal his mom had prepared for him.
Julio’s supported his mother with his meager salary. They lived together in a modest home not far from the plant. Julio’s was always careful to save for a rainy day so that he could care for his mother properly.
As he started his car he noticed he was getting low on gas. Better stop and fill up before I get home, he thought. He usually followed the same path through the side streets to get to his house. This time he took the expressway so that he could fill up at a station that had reasonable gas prices.
Driving along in the right lane, he noticed a car pulled over to the side barely off his lane. As he got closer, he saw that the driver was slumped over the steering wheel. Should he stop?
He was ‘Oh so tired,’ and almost out of gas. On the other hand, this was a person in trouble, and not many people drive by at this time of night. Julio’s decided to pull over.
This was a person in great need. Julio’s noticed the bullet hole in the windshield. He also saw that the driver was beaten unconscious and robbed. His clothing was torn and a lap top computer case was thrown empty on the floor of the front seat. What to do?
Julio’s gently carried the man to his car and carefully laid him down in the back seat. He drove directly to the nearest emergency room and notified the people at the desk that he had an injured person in his car. He explained the circumstances under which he brought this injured man and waited for the police so that he could answer questions for a police report.
The police had many questions, as did the hospital attendants. Julio’s stayed as long as was necessary to make sure everything was taken care of. He left twenty dollars at the desk in case it was necessary since the victim’s wallet was taken too. He even led the police back to the victim’s car so that he could help gather all the clues possible that led to determining what happened.
Finally, the police told him to go home. Julio’s made his way home by way of a gas station, thinking that tomorrow after work he’d check up on the man and make sure everything was all right. What a long day it had been!
Who was the person who practiced philanthropy?
Note: This story is a modern-day version of the parable The Good Samaritan as retold by Joyce Rogers.
Someone Should
Setting: Anywhere Elementary School, the hallway. This rather new school building has large carpeted hallways with great lighting and nice big windows. In the middle of the hallway is unsightly litter strewn here and there. It is a few minutes after dismissal on a Friday afternoon.
Two fifth graders walk through the hall:
Boy I: What a mess! I can’t believe the trash in this hallway.
Boy II: You said it. They should pick up this gross mess. Who dumped all
this litter here anyway?
Boy I: I don’t know but someone should pick it up. It’s disgusting.
Boy II: Let’s get going, or I’ll be late for practice.
Three teachers walk through the hall next.
Teacher I: Oh my goodness someone should tell the principal about this mess.
Teacher II: I just can’t understand why these kids are so slovenly.
Teacher III: You wonder what their bedrooms look like. Can’t we get someone to
pick this litter up?
Teacher II: We must bring this problem up at our next staff meeting. Someone
should do something about this.
Teacher I: Someone should, but I’m late for an appointment. Have a nice
weekend!
Two administrators come down the hall next.
Administrator I: We can’t have our buildings looking like this. Someone should
make a report about this trashy hallway.
Administrator II: It hasn’t been called to my attention before, but you’re right. This
hallway is a disaster. Someone should get on this problem right
away.
Administrator I: How does your schedule look for next week?
Administrator II: I could squeeze a meeting in next Wednesday.
Administrator I: Great! Let’s plan to discuss how someone should alleviate this
problem.
One kindergartner is walking down the hall after school.
Kindergartner: Wow, what a mess. It does look yucky. I guess it wouldn’t take
long to pick it up. It really isn’t hard to do because the trash can is
just a few steps away. I’ll just quickly do it and go home. There,
that looks better. The first thing I’ll do when I get home is wash
my hands!
Comparing the Stories
| |
The Lion and the Mouse
|
The Good San Franciscan
|
Someone Should
|
|
What is the need?
|
|
|
|
|
Who has the need?
|
|
|
|
| Who is in the community? |
|
|
|
| Who fills the need? |
|
|
|
| What talent or treasure was given? What did it cost to give? |
|
|
|
| What benefit does the community experience from that giving or sharing? |
|
|
|
| What is the reward for the one or ones who shared? |
|
|
|
| What would have happened if the need had not been met? |
|
|
|