Learning to Give, Curriculum Division of The LEAGUE

The LEAGUE

Exploring Philanthropic Motivations: The Drive (8th)
Lesson 1:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Focus Question(s):

How might individuals and society address the issues of poverty, homelessness and hunger, and their underlying causes?

NOTE: Prior to this lesson, use the Blue Sky Activity in which students envision a better world.  If you already have a Blue Sky display, revisit it before beginning this lesson.
 

LEAGUE Coaches: After teaching this lesson, please complete a short evaluation.
LEAGUE Learning Link(s)
Post Service Reflection

Purpose:

Students learn about and discuss the motivations for giving. They explore applications of these motivations to their own lives and to The Drive goal of addressing poverty, hunger, and homelessness.

Duration:

Objectives:

The learner will:

  • respond to a poem about working for change.
  • give examples of motivations for giving and serving.
  • write a paragraph or poem about personal motivations.

Materials:

  • Overhead transparency or student copies of Attachment One: Motivations for Giving
  • Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul by Canfield, Hansen and Kirberger
Handout 1
Motivations for Giving

Teacher Preparation:

It is important to be sensitive to the possibility that someone in your class may have some personal experience with homelessness, hunger and poverty.

Instructional Procedure(s):

Anticipatory Set:

Read aloud the poem “Passing the Dream” by Penny Caldwell from Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul. Project the poem for students to read a second time silently or in pairs.

  • Ask students what they think the poem encourages us to do. Ask them to point out lines that express thoughts and questions they have had. Ask them what it means to work for change. Have them each make a short, personal list of things they want to change.
  • Review the meaning of common good (what is best for all, not just self-interest). Tell the students that philanthropy is giving time, talent, or treasure for the common good. Ask the students if taking action for the common good is an obligation? Is giving and serving a right or a responsibility? Ask students to debate these questions, giving supporting arguments for their answers. They may come up with a better term than obligation or responsibility.
  • Lead the discussion to ask, "Why do we give to others?  What inspires us to want to help others in need?" Listen to student responses and list some words they come up with on the display board (to make things better, to be kind, because she did something nice for me, to make friends, etc).
  • Tell the students that some experts have studied this question and come up with seven motivations for giving and serving:
  1. community
  2. religion
  3. good business
  4. social function
  5. giving back
  6. family tradition
  7. selfless concern for others
  • Display Attachment One: Motivations for Giving on the overhead projector or distribute copies. Read through and discuss the seven motivations. Refer to the list students generated about why we give, and match up their ideas with the seven motivations. Look for similarities and differences. Encourage the students to give specific examples of philanthropy and identify the possible motivations (e.g. Boy Scout project is a social function and a family tradition).
  • Introduce three new terms and challenge the students to use constructive (constructing meaning based on what they already know) and structural (splitting words in to parts to determine meaning) analysis to decode the vocabulary. Use a dictionary or the definitions below to confirm the meanings of the words. Then discuss how these three terms relate to the seven motivations for giving.
  1. enlightened self-interest (to sacrifice a small part of their time and resources to the benefit of the whole, which, in turn, benefits themselves)
  2. altruism (selfless concern for the welfare of others)
  3. egoism (theory of ethics that sets as its goal the benefit, pleasure, or greatest good of oneself alone)
  • Have the students write a paragraph or poem about their own personal motivations for giving. They should refer to vocabulary or concepts from the seven motivations and the three new terms above. Also, have them use as a reference the personal list of things they want to change sparked by the poem at the beginning of the lesson.
  • Discuss and come to a decision about what the class will do to collect items and support The Drive.

Assessment:

Student writing includes articulate explanation of personal motivations and reflects understanding of new concepts.

LEAGUE Learning Link(s): (click to view)

Extension:

Discuss the concept of serial reciprocity. Read the poem "Smile" on page 123 of Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul.

Post Service Reflection: (click to view)

Bibliographical References:

  • Caldwell, Penny; 1997; “Passing the Dream.” and “Smile” In Canfield, Jack; Hansen, Mark Victor; Kirberger, Kimberly; Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul; pp 123, 272-274 Deerfield Beach, FL. Health Communications, Inc.
  • Prince, Russ A. and Karen M. File. The Seven Faces of Philanthropy. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2001: 0-7879-6057-8.

Lesson Developed and Piloted by:

Thomas Webb
Fulton Schools
Fulton Middle School
Middleton, MI 48856

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Motivations for Giving

Motivations for Charitable Giving

  • Some people give because of their sense of belonging to a community. They give because they consider nonprofit organizations more effective at delivering services and more attuned with community needs.
     
  • Some people give because they feel it is a moral obligation. They believe everyone needs to take responsibility for creating a better world and should not expect personal recognition for volunteering time, talent or treasure.
     
  • Some people see philanthropy as “good business”. They are motivated by the personal tax and other financial benefits philanthropy gives.
     
  • Some people enjoy the socializing and entertainment that are a part of contributing to a good cause.
     
  • Some people “pay back” in return for what they received in life.
     
  • Some people see philanthropy as a family tradition. They were raised in a family that stressed the importance of giving.
     
  • Some people feel a sense of purpose and personal fulfillment when they contribute. They see themselves as the true philanthropists who are not concerned with business or personal gain.

 

From The Seven Faces of Philanthropy by Russ A. Prince and Karen M. File

Philanthropy Framework:

Submit a Comment

Unit Contents:

Overview:Exploring Philanthropic Motivations: The Drive (8th) Summary

Lessons:

1.
Exploring Philanthropic Motivations: The Drive (8th)

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.

Copyright © LearningToGive.org