Learning to Give, Philanthropy education resources that teach giving and civic engagement

generationOn

Find Lesson Plans Browse Resources
Understanding Justice, Kindness and Tolerance
(9th Grade)
Lesson 1:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Focus Question(s):

What is a world citizen's responsibility to promote and advocate for justice and kindness?

NOTE: Prior to this lesson, use the Blue Sky Activity in which students envision a better world.  If you already have a Blue Sky display, revisit it before beginning this lesson.

Purpose:

The purpose of this lesson is to expose the learners to the role that self-betrayal and self-deception play in perpetuating racism and prejudice. In addition, the learners identify ways they can advocate for tolerance, justice, and kindness in their own school, community, and even the world.

Duration:

One 50 Minute Class Period

Objectives:

The learners will:

  • identify and explain how self-betrayal and self-deception lead one to treat others with disrespect.
  • analyze a historical example of self-betrayal leading to racism.
  • discuss personal responsibility to advocate for tolerance, justice, and kindness in their school, community, and world.

Materials:

  • Projection copy or handout for each learner of Attachment One: Self-Deception
  • Learner copies of Attachment Two: Racism and Self-Deception
  • Projection copy of Attachment Three: Bus Driver’s Self-Justifying Views
  • (Optional) Learner copies of Attachment Four: Reflecting on Racism and the Box
Handout 1
Self Deception
Handout 2
Racism and Self-Deception
Handout 3
Bus Driver’s Self-Justifying Views
Handout 4
Reflecting on Racism and the Box - Extension

Instructional Procedure(s):

Teacher Note: Make prior arrangements with two student volunteers to act out an improvisation where one person unknowingly drops a pencil and the other person considers picking up the pencil (feeling it is the right thing to do) but then does nothing.

Anticipatory Set:
Have the two volunteers perform the pencil-dropping scene before the rest of the class. Following the improvisation, ask the class what they saw happen and what they think was going on in the students' minds. It may be necessary to repeat the scene to spark more observations.

  • Present the information on Attachment One: Self-Deception using either transparencies or handouts. This lays out the logical progression of a person going against his/her instinct to help others and ending up in a "box" separated from humanity.
  • Ask the question, "How could the person who did not pick up the pencil justify doing nothing?" Write a sample of their explanations on the display board (not my job, I'm too cool, I don't know him, etc.) Ask the further quesiton, "With these thoughts in mind, how do you think this person views himself and how does he view the person he did not help?" Write a few of the responses on the display board (cool/not cool, etc.).
  • Ask the students to think briefly about the following questions and then discuss their thoughts with a partner for a couple minutes: "If this scenario happened repeatedly in various forms every day, how would the person who is not helped begin to feel about himself/herself? How would the person who chooses not to help others begin to feel about himself/herself? And how would that affect the whole community?" Ask a few partners to share their thoughts with the whole group.
  • Pose the question, "How might the feelings between the two have been different if the second person had picked up the pencil?" 
  • Distribute Attachment Two: Racism and Self-Deception and read through the instructions with the class. Allow the learners to work independently on this assignment prior to putting them into groups of two or three to share and discuss their responses.
  • Create a T-chart of Attachment Three: Bus Driver’s Self-Justifying Views for the class to complete together (projected or on large paper). Have volunteers use words and phrases from their Racism and Self-Deception worksheet under the two columns. Discuss the words and phrases as a class. Ask students to analyze how the intolerance shown in the example contributed to society’s disintegration.
  • Lead the class in a brainstorming session of ways they can promote tolerance, justice, and kindness as they participate in a service project related to Martin Luther King, Jr. Day.
  • (Optional) Distribute Attachment Four: Reflecting on Racism and the Box. Have students complete this as an extension of the lesson.

Assessment:

  • Base the assessment for this lesson on teacher observation of class work, discussion, and interactive participation. Measure the learners' understanding of the concepts: self-betrayal, self-deception, racism, justice, and kindness.

Learning Link(s): (click to view)

School/Home Connection:

  • Interactive Parent / Student Homework:
    (Optional) Assign as homework Attachment Four: Reflecting on Racism and the Box. The learner can discuss his/her paragraph and ideas with family members as a way to internalize the concept of tolerance, justice, and kindness as antidotes to racism and prejudice. 

Cross-Curriculum Extensions:

  • Assign as extra credit Attachment Four: Reflecting on Racism and the Box. Students write a reflection paragraph based on the class discussion.

Reflection: (click to view)

Bibliographical References:

Teacher Information:

Lesson Developed By:

Lydia Alvarez
University High
Newark, NJ 77108

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Self Deception

Self-Betrayal: An act contrary to what I feel I should do for another

Example of Self-Betrayal

When I betray myself, I begin to see the world in a way that justifies my self-betrayal. I deceive myself, and my view of reality becomes distorted.

How I start to see myself How I start to see the other person
Too cool to move Uncool
Loyal to my friends Antisocial
Worthy of friendship Unworthy of friendship

When I betray myself, I enter "the box."

In the box, I deceive myself that others aren't important.

I see people as objects rather than fellow humans.

I actively resist what the humanity of others calls me to do for them.

By being in the box, I provoke others
to be in the box.

In the box, we invite mutual disrespect and, in this way, give each other reasons to stay in the box.

Over time, certain boxes become characteristic of me, and I
carry them with me. These are prejudices and self-fulfilling labels.

What does not work inside the box:

  1. Trying to change others
  2. Doing my best to understand others  
  3. Communicating with others
  4. Implementing new skills or techniques
 
 
 

The way out of the box:

 

Living "Out of the Box"

  1. Don’t try to be perfect. Do try to do better.
     
  2. Don’t look for others’ boxes. Do look for your own.
     
  3. Don’t accuse others of being in the box.
     
  4. Do try to stay out of the box yourself.
     
  5. Don’t give up on yourself when you discover you’ve been in the box. Do keep trying.
     
  6. Don’t deny you’ve been in the box when you have been.
     
  7. Do apologize, and then keep marching forward, trying to be more helpful to others in the future. 
     
  8. Don’t focus on what others are doing wrong. Do focus on what you can do right to help. 
     
  9. Don’t worry about whether others are helping you. Do worry whether you are helping others.

Used with permission from

Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting Out of the Box. The Arbinger Institute (Editor). San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, 2000. ISBN: 1576750949

Handout 2Print Handout 2

Racism and Self-Deception

Name___________________________________________

Directions: Refer to the information given below and complete the diagram. Then decide how you think self-betrayal changed the way the bus driver saw himself and how he saw the black passengers.

Setting: Montgomery, Alabama, 1955

Scene: A bus driver is asked by an officer to move the board that indicates the line behind which the black passengers are allowed to sit. The bus driver feels that he should refuse this request, since that would mean that two black passengers would have to stand unnecessarily. However, the bus driver betrays this feeling and does what the officer asked him to do.
 

Handout 3Print Handout 3

Bus Driver’s Self-Justifying Views

Handout 4Print Handout 4

Reflecting on Racism and the Box - Extension

Definitions:

Discrimination: Treatment or consideration based on class or category rather than individual merit
Prejudice: A negative opinion formed without knowledge or examination of the facts
Racism: Discrimination or prejudice based on race

 

Directions: Write a paragraph explaining how “being in the box” applies to racism. Use the definitions above and the questions below to guide your response.
  • If people of two races are “in the box” in regard to their attitudes toward each other, how does their view of reality become distorted?
  • Which “boxes” or self-deceptions do people often carry around with them?
  • What kind of mistreatment results from races being “in the box” in relation to one another?
  • What are the advantages of being “out of the box” in their attitudes toward people of other races?
     

Grading Rubric

Possible Score: 30 pts.

Format: One paragraph, typed
Double-spaced, 12 pt. font
Correct spelling and proper use of mechanics
 
/5
/5
/5
Content: Depth of thought
Understanding of concepts (racism, the box)
Representation of viewpoints other than own
/5
/5
/5

 

Philanthropy Framework:

Submit a Comment

Unit Contents:

Overview:Understanding Justice, Kindness and Tolerance
(9th Grade) Summary

Lessons:

1.
Understanding Justice, Kindness and Tolerance
(9th Grade)

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.