6th-8th Grade
Subjects:
Arts, Language Arts, Philanthropy and Social Studies
Key Words/Concepts click to view
| ART: | Visual Arts |
| ELA: | Analyze/Interpret; Audience; Brainstorming; Communicate; Compare/Contrast; Creative Writing; Knight scholarship; Main Idea; Peer Review; Presentations; Reflection; Teamwork; Viewing; Writing Process |
| PHIL: | Advocacy; Civil Society; Common Good; Empower; Leadership; Reflection; Responsibility; Service |
| SOC: | Civic Responsibility/Virtue; Civil Rights; Common Good; Democracy; Government; Rights/Responsibilities; Volunteerism |
Purpose:
In this lesson, learners identify different levels of participation in a democracy. Each student writes a statement describing what type of citizen he or she would like to be. In groups of 4-6 students, the learners create an audio or visual presentation advocating for civic responsibility. They share their presentations with an outside audience. Students also reflect on their personal role in "writing history."
Duration:
Three Fifty-Minute Lessons, plus time to create a group presentation
Objectives:
The learner will:
- identify characteristics of participatory citizenship.
- work in a small production group of 5-8 students to create a presentation as a piece of advocacy.
- view the presentations of all the learners.
- reflect on the impact of the project.
Service Experience:
Although this lesson contains a service project example, decisions about service plans and implementation should be made by students, as age appropriate.
Learners create a presentation (audio, video, or other technology) that communicates a statement of advocacy for a specific issue or to promote personal responsibility in a democratic society to act for the common good. The students determine an appropriate audience and venue for their piece of advocacy in order to teach others about their responsibility as "We the people."
Materials:
- copies of Attachment One: Three Types of Citizen or teacher printout for projecting on the wall screen
- learner copies of Attachment Two: Rubric
- group copies of Attachment Three: Guidelines for Project
- computer and Internet access to show an online video (see Bibliographical References)
- various equipment/supplies for audio/visual project based on available resources (e.g., Flip video, audio recording device, cell phone with video capability, computers, paper, markers, etc.)
- Handout 1
- Three Types of Citizen
- Handout 2
- Rubric
- Handout 3
- Guidelines for Planning
- Handout 4
- Service-Learning Project Planning
Teacher Preparation:
You will need student access to one or more video cameras. One camera can be shared with several groups if they take turns. The Flip video camcorder is an inexpensive option that is easy to use and includes simple editing software. See the Flip video camcorder online. Look for their donor matching program.
Instructional Procedure(s):
Day One:
Anticipatory Set:
Write the following question on the board: What does ideal participatory citizenship look like? Ask the students to brainstorm examples of participatory citizenship (e.g., voting, following the laws, sharing and helping others, etc.). Write their ideas on the board.
- Present to the students the three types of democratic citizenship as described by Joel Westheimer. (See Attachment One: Three Types of Citizen.)
- Ask the students to categorize their brainstormed list on the board into these three categories. Then ask them to decide for themselves what type of citizen they want to be. Have each student write a statement describing their own citizenship and what they wish for a better world/country/community. Have them include the following information: What type of citizen they want to be, what issues do they care about, what their personal goals are, how they want to impact others to make the world a better place. Give the students 10-15 minutes to write.
- Pair up the students for peer editing. Give them time to help each other give feedback, revise, edit, and write a final version of their statements. They should hand in their statements by the end of the class period. Teacher Note: Before the next class period, group the students' statements by common interests and goals. Use these as a guide to form groups of 4-6 students for the final project of the unit.
Day Two:
Anticipatory Set:
Show the students an example of a video that makes a statement of advocacy. "The Girl Effect" (see Bibliographical References) is a good example because it makes the viewer think about an issue and suggests a way to take action for the common good. After the video, discuss the main message of the video and how viewers can take action to address the featured issue.
- Tell the learners that they will be working in groups to create videos (or other approved presentations) to share statements of democratic responsibility. These presentations will give information and inspire viewers to take action toward an issue as responsible citizens.
- Give the learners copies of Attachment Two: Rubric. Go over the expectations and possible formats. Find out what resources the students already have (video cameras, audio devises, software, etc.). Describe your expectations for each format and brainstorm possible audiences for the presentations.
- Return the students' statements from the previous class period. Tell them these statements may be the starting point for their group discussions. Assign learners to groups of 4-6 (based on the common interests expressed in the statements). Each group discusses what they would like to communicate about civic responsibility, the nature of democracy, and the importance of taking action for the common good in a democratic society. In their groups, they should start to determine the following: issue to address/main idea, audience, presentation format, and initial responsibilities.
- The student groups may work in class and/or outside of class over several days to complete their project. Set a deadline for presenting the projects to the class. Guide the students as they work on the projects. Give each group a copy of Attachment Three: Guidelines for Planning.
Day Three (after several days of production):
- Make sure you have all the media required for students to show their presentations to the whole class.
- Allow time for each group to present their project and discuss the impact of the project on themselves and their intended audience.
- After all presentations, discuss what they should do next. Guide the students as they discuss who else might be interested in their presentations and what they could do next to advocate for their issue. This may spark a discussion of organizing an event to address a featured issue. See Next Steps and Extension for creating a student-led service-learning project.
- Final reflection, show the same quote as in Lesson Two. Have the learners write a reflection about their personal responsibility to form and "write" history.
- "History is yours to make. It is not owned or written by someone else for you to learn. History is not just the story you read; it is the one you write. It is the one you remember or denounce or relate to others. It is not predetermined. Every action, every decision, however small, is relevant to its course. History is filled with horror and replete with hope. You shape the balance." (inscribed on the exit of the Canadian War Museum in Ottawa as noted by Joel Westheimer.)
Next Steps:
- Continue to reflect and guide the students as they publish their presentations. Help them find venues, community partners, and publishing options. Have the learners collect data and measure impact, if available. After the presentations are public, have each student write a reflection about their learning.
- Work with the learners to design an appropriate demonstration to a group of students, families, and/or community members. The demonstration includes a presentaion and communicates the impact the learners have made on themselves and others.
Assessment:
Use Attachment One: Rubric as a guide for assessing student work on the final presentation.
Cross-Curriculum Extensions:
Say, "Our group has similar goals and motivations for promoting civic responsibility." Tell the students to write a sentence reflecting on what this group could accomplish (based on the statements they heard in the group presentations). Allow the students some time to write. Ask a few volunteers to share their thoughts.
- Project an image of Attachment Four: Service-Learning Project Planning onto the wall screen. Use it as a guide to plan a service-learning project. Discuss and come to consensus for a service-learning project based on community needs and learner motivations, especially related to promoting justice and protecting rights of others. Note: It may take several days to collect data and design the best project for the group.
- Carry out the project plan, gathering resources, conducting research, and setting goals.
- Before, during, and after the project, reflect on the goals and progress, adjusting expectations and plans for improvement.
- Have the students present the data from the project in an appropriate format.
- Invite guests to a demonstration event. Have students show their presentations, describe the service-learning project, and report the impact results.
Lesson Developed By:
Betsy Flikkema
Associate Director
Learning to Give
Barbara Dillbeck
Director
Learning to Give
Handouts:
Three Types of Citizen
Joel Westheimer, researcher at Ottawa University reports there are three categories of citizenship were identified from a study of democratic citizenship. Examine the table below to learn the description of each category, as well as a sample action and the core assumptions.
|
Kinds of Citizens
|
|
Personally Responsible Citizen
|
|
|
|
- Acts responsibly in his/her community
- Works and pays taxes
- Obeys laws
- Recycles, gives blood
- Volunteers to lend a hand in times of crisis
|
- Active member of community organizations and/or improvement efforts
- Organizes community efforts to care for those in need, promote economic development, or clean up environment
- Knows how government agencies work
- Knows strategies for accomplishing collective tasks
|
- Critically assesses social, political, and economic structures to see beyond surface outcomes
- Seeks out and addresses areas of injustice
- Knows about social movements and how to effect systemic change
|
|
Sample Action: Contributes food to a food drive
|
Sample Action: Helps to organize a food drive
|
Sample Action: Explores why people are hungry and acts to solve root causes
|
|
Core Assumption: To solve social problems and improve society, citizens must have good character; they must be honest, responsible, and law-abiding members of the community.
|
Core Assumption: To solve social problems and improve society, citizens must actively participate and take leadership positions within established systems and community structures.
|
Core Assumption: To solve social problems and improve society, citizens must question and change established systems and structures when they reproduce patterns of injustice over time.
|
In summary, if Participatory Citizens are organizing the food drive and Personally Responsible Citizens are donating the food, the Social Justice-Oriented Citizens are asking why people are hungry and acting on what they discover.
Rubric
Demonstrate the importance of a civil society by sharing your interest in participating in democracy. Create a presentation that encourages or inspires others to participate in democracy.
Think about your role in improving the world and what you would like to communicate to the citizens of this democracy about their role as democratic citizens?
Choose a format for sharing your vision:
|
Create a Keynote, PowerPoint, or Google Docs presentation.
|
Create a movie using a FLIP video camera.
|
Make a poster
(on paper or using glogster.com).
|
|
Create a Website.
|
Blog about a topic.
|
Create a comic strip (on paper or using Comic Life).
|
|
Write a letter of advocacy.
|
Create a podcast.
|
Write a poem, song, play, or puppet show to perform.
|
Rubric Outline:
Presentation has a clear audience.
- The audience is identified and matches the tone and message.
- The audience is not identified, but the tone and message are clear.
- The audience and message do not match.
Use correct grammar, spelling, and style.
- The grammar, spelling, and style are grade-level appropriate.
- The grammar, spelling, and style are 80% accurate.
- The grammar, spelling, and style are 50% accurate.
Be creative and create something new and innovative.
- The presentation is new and different.
- The ideas are new, but the presentation is familiar.
- The presentation is unique, but the ideas are familiar.
- The presentation and ideas are not new.
Use effective communication.
- The message is communicated clearly and fits the goals of the project.
- The message and goals are inconsistent.
- The message is unclear.
Make your presentation attractive.
- The presentation is neat, consistent, and colorful.
- The presentation is attractive, but contains some sloppiness.
- The presentation looks like a rough draft.
Share responsibilities.
- Each member of the group contributed appropriately.
- Some members contributed more than others.
- Some members did not take adequate responsibility.
Guidelines for Planning
Names: __________________________________________
Title of Project: _____________________________________ Due Date: _________________________________
The final outcome of this project is a video (or other approved presentation format) that promotes responsible democracy. The documentary should inspire viewers to take action to be responsible citizens.
Make a Plan.
- Determine your timeline of the project. Look at the final due date and plan the following steps:
- Decide the main issue/focus of the presentation.
- Determine an appropriate audience and format for the presentation.
- Discuss the focus and storyline of the documentary.
- Determine group roles (camera, script, interviewer, phone contact, etc.).
- Write an outline for the script; include a clearly stated purpose.
- All group members should contribute to the writing and editing of the script.
- Contact the audience or publisher of the presentation, if needed.
- Create the presentation, using images, video, music, and text, as appropriate.
- Check for spelling, neatness, and style.
- Give credit for research and resources.
Guidelines:
- The final presentation will be shared with students and other audiences to teach them about democracy and inspire others to serve and take action.
- The presentation should be 3 to 6 minutes long.
- The presentation should include text and images that support the main idea.
- Include music in the background of audio/visual presentations.
- The rough plan should be approved by the teacher by this date: _______________________
Service-Learning Project Planning
|
Component
|
Activities
|
Who, What, Where?
|
|
Investigation
(What do we need in our community, and how do we know it is a need? What statistics show this is a need? What is our expected outcome and how will we measure it?)
|
|
|
|
Preparation
(How can we meet this need? What resources do we have and need?)
|
|
|
|
Action
(How will we execute our project? What partners can we engage? What is our budget?)
|
|
|
|
Reflection
(Why did this help/not help our community?)
|
|
|
|
Demonstration
(Create a presentation to show others the good that we have done!)
|
|
|