Strand PHIL.II Philanthropy and Civil Society
Standard PCS 03. Philanthropy and Economics
Benchmark HS.11 Analyze the impact of volunteerism on the economy of communities.
Benchmark HS.5 Give examples of stewardship decisions throughout history and in current events.
Strand PHIL.III Philanthropy and the Individual
Standard PI 01. Reasons for Individual Philanthropy
Benchmark HS.1 Define and give examples of motivations for giving and serving.
Benchmark HS.4 Cite historical examples of citizen actions that affected the common good.
Strand PHIL.IV Volunteering and Service
Standard VS 01. Needs Assessment
Benchmark HS.2 Research the need in the school, neighborhood, local community, state, nation, or world.
This lesson is intended to stimulate the learner’s thinking about recycling; who does it, what do they do, and why do they do it? The learners will investigate motivations for recycling that go beyond the economics of the practice and explore other thoughts and ideas that motivate some people to be stewards for the common good.
The learner will:
- explore the characteristics and motivations of those who recycle.
- explore the economics of recycling.
- conduct a survey to determine awareness and involvement in recycling endeavors of individuals of different ages.
- write a convincing argument for why recycling/stewardship of natural resources is worth the time and effort.
- Recycling Survey Worksheet (Handout One). Five copies per learner.
- Recommended Web Sites (Handout Two). One per learner.
- The Rubric for Response (Handout Three). One per learner.
Interactive Parent / Student Homework: The learners are required to administer the Recycling Survey Worksheet (Handout One) survey to a minimum of four individuals; one of those individuals must be an elementary or middle school student, one must be a high school student peer, one must be an adult twenty to fifty-five years old, and one must be someone who is fifty-sixty years old or older.The only identification to be placed on the survey sheet is the age span of the person filling out the form.
- See Recommended Web Sites (Handout Two) for a comprehensive listing.
- For Additional Related Units/Lessons: www.learningtogive.org
Anticipatory Set: Ask for a show of hands of the learners who know at least one person who recycles. Tell them that you’re not interested in names, but you would like to know a little more about these recyclers.Ask those who raised their hand to share the approximate age of the person or persons they know who recycle something and record these approximate ages randomly on the display board. Then ask what these individuals recycle and randomly list these items on the board. Finally ask the learners why they think that these people recycle what they do, and note their responses with a word or phrase randomly placed on the display board. Encourage the learners to look over the display board and determine if any identifiable patterns can be found from what is listed there and why it might be considered a pattern.
Following this discussion, tell the learners that you are interested in knowing what they already know about recycling and to do that they are being asked to respond to a true/false survey.
Distribute the True/False Recycling Survey Worksheet (Handout One) and have the learners complete it.
When the survey is completed pair the learners up to compare their answers and encourage them to discuss and change, if necessary, any of their responses.
Announce that the first ten statements found on the Recycling Survey Worksheet are true and that you would hope that the last two were true as well. Encourage any reflection on the part of the learners about the statements and check to see if there were any statements that really surprised them in terms of new learning.
Ask the learners how well they think that younger learners or their peers would do if given this test? How about their family members? Senior Citizens?
Tell each learner that they will be given four additional extra blank surveys with which to conduct an experiment in which they will be required to administer this survey to four different individuals; one of these individuals must be an elementary or middle school student, one must be a high school student peer, one must be an adult twenty-one to fifty-five years old, and one must be someone who is fifty to sixty years old or older. The only identification to be placed on the survey sheet is the age span of the person filling out the form. This survey will be assigned as homework.
Have the learners share their predictions as to which age group they think will do the better job on the survey and their reasons for their predictions. If possible determine a consensus of opinion.
Share with the learners that individuals who recycle are often referred to as “stewards of the Earth’s natural resources”. Have them reflect on what this phrase might mean by first identifying some of the Earth’s natural resources (i.e. water, air, plants/trees, minerals/oil, etc.), and secondly by defining “stewardship” (Definition: The conducting, supervising, or managing of something; especially: the careful and responsible management of something entrusted to one's care.)
Remind the learners of the impact recycling has on the environment based on the results of their Recycling Survey Worksheet (Handout One) that clearly showed that economically recycling/stewardship of natural resources makes good sense.
Ask the learners to find other reasons for recycling to better be able to respond to that person who says, “If it all boils down to economics, I have more money than time. It’s just too inconvenient for me recycle.” Give the learners an opportunity to begin a web search of recycling rationale and benefits beginning with Recommended Web Sites (Handout Two).
Based on the readings of the various web searches, have the learners write a 75-100 word point-of-view- persuasive response to the person’s comment about not having time and the inconvenience of recycling based upon The Rubric for Response (Handout Three).
Conclude this lesson by having the learners orally share their 75-100 word point-of-view- persuasive response with the rest of the class and allow time for questions and reflective interaction.
The assessment for this lesson is based on the learners’ participation in the class discussions, the depth of thought and insights shared, the completion of the out-of-class surveys, and the production of a written rebuttal of the expressed concern for the amount of time and inconvenience recycling requires of an individual based on the Rubric for Response (Handout Three).