Learning to Give, Curriculum Division of The LEAGUE

The LEAGUE

Who Should Do It?
Lesson 2:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Purpose:

Students will identify that the economy is divided into four sectors which have varied but sometimes overlapping responsibilities. They will discuss reasons for the existence of the nonprofit sector, identify and describe the work of foundations and understand the purpose of an organizations mission statement.

Duration:

Two Fifty-Minute Class Periods

Objectives:

The learners will:

  • identify the four sectors of the economy and give examples of their responsibilities.
  • define “foundation” and explain how they contribute to the common good through grants.
  • describe how a mission statement identifies the focus of a foundation.

Service Experience:

Although this lesson contains a service project example, decisions about service plans and implementation should be made by students, as age appropriate.
Students’ completed posters will be placed on exhibit in the school so that other classes may learn about the work of foundations.

Materials:

  • Who Should Do It? (Attachment One)
  • Definition and Examples of Nonprofit Organizations (Attachment Two)
  • Foundation Poster Rubrics (Attachment Three)
Handout 1
Wind Beneath My Wings
Handout 2
Definition and Examples of Nonprofit Organizations
Handout 3
Foundation Poster Rubrics

Instructional Procedure(s):

Anticipatory Set:
Using the home assignment from Lesson One: Limits of Power, ask students to share the adults’ (guardians’) experiences of when they asked for advice before making a decision. Survey the class quickly to see if it was advantageous or not to ask for advice before making a decision.

  • Ask the students the following question, “If something needs to be done, is it always better to do it yourself?” Put students in teams of three and let them mull over the answer to this question. After three minutes, let the teams share their answers with the whole group. Put a T-chart on the board and record students’ answers according to the appropriate category:
    Advantages of Doing it Yourself    Disadvantages of Doing it Yourself

     
  • Have the learners reach a conclusion to the question. The answer will probably be that sometimes it is best to do it yourself, whereas at other times it is better to have someone else take action. Reasons might include: more skill, more funds, better incentive, more private, knows how to do it right, etc.

     
  • Distribute Who Should Do It? (Attachment One). Once again working in three- person teams, have students indicate their preferences as to who should have responsibility to do the action listed. Give ten minutes for this exercise. Share answers and allow students to give the reasons behind their selections.
    There will be more than one possible answer for several of the examples. For example, schools are the responsibility of (state) governments, but churches and religious groups operate parochial schools and corporations and nonprofit organizations also run schools. The University of Michigan is a public university run by an elected board but the University of Detroit/Mercy is a private college operated by two religious organizations.
    Sometimes the responsibility for a service is a shared one, depending on the reasons behind why something is done. While there are a lot of things that governments (city, state, national, school district, etc.) take responsibility for, they cannot do everything; nor should they. For example, state governments take responsibility for the care of children who cannot continue to live with their families for one reason or another. Even though states maintain “child welfare” and other programs, other groups also maintain these kinds of programs for children (Catholic Social Services, Children’s Defense Fund, Jewish Relief Fund etc.). This is an example of a special reason why a nonprofit group maintains a service which is already being carried out by the government.
    There are also some things that are done by nonprofits because the government is not doing a good job of carrying out its responsibilities. Can the learners give examples of this (soup kitchens, animal shelters, homeless shelters, etc.)?

     
  • Explain the difference between a “for profit” and a “nonprofit” organization. “For profit” businesses seek to earn a profit for their shareholders who have invested in the business or for their owners who make their living from it. The income of “nonprofit” organizations is not used for the benefit or private gain of stockholders, directors, or any other persons with an interest in the company. It is used to provide a needed service for the common good. Since its employees are giving of their time and talent, and are probably making less money than they could in the “for profit” area, they may be considered philanthropists if their motivation is to help people. Brainstorm a list of nonprofit organizations. (Nonprofit organizations are numerous and fit into nine major groups: arts, culture, humanities; education; environment and animals; health; human services; international, foreign affairs; public societal benefit; religion related; mutual/ membership benefit. The examples given by the learners will fit into these categories.) Definition and Examples of Nonprofit Organizations (Attachment Two) will provide helpful information for the teacher.

     
  • One type of nonprofit organization that exists in all states and many communities is a foundation. Define foundation as an organization created from designated funds from which the income is distributed as grants to not-for-profit organizations or, in some cases, to people. Make sure students understand that a grant is money given to support a person, organization, project or program within guidelines. It is not a loan and does not have to be repaid. Ask students to name a foundation (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Ford Foundation, Rockefeller Foundation, Carnegie Corporation, National Science Foundation, etc.).

     
  • Put the term “mission statement” on the chalkboard. Ask the learners to define the “mission statement” of a school. Once students have decided on this, ask them to make an inference (going from a specific example to a generalization) about the definition/purpose of a mission statement. Explain that foundations have a mission statement or focus for what they do. Ask students what they would expect a mission statement for a foundation to look like. Give your school’s mission statement as an example to help students decide what a foundation mission statement might look like.

     
  • To give students the experience of learning about various foundations, split the group into small teams. Have the teams go to the Learning to Give Web site at http://learningtogive.org/resources/foundations/foundations.asp where they will find information on foundations. Let teams select a foundation to investigate. Distribute poster boards or large sheets of paper, Foundation Poster Rubrics (Attachment Three) and allow teams to design a poster that will show the work of their foundation. OPTION: Students may opt to research other foundations that are not listed on this Web site. Use http://www.guidestar.org to find other foundations for study.

     
  • When posters are completed, exhibit them in a hall display case or media center display for other classes to view.

Assessment:

The completed poster will serve as the assessment for this lesson.

Bibliographical References:

Lesson Developed and Piloted by:

Evelyn Nash
Curriculum Consultant
Learning to Give

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Wind Beneath My Wings

Directions: Put an “X” in the box or boxes next to each action which describes which economic sector you think should be responsible for each action.

Action Family Government For Profit Business Nonprofit Organizations
Deliver the mail
       
Build automobiles
       
Take care of ill persons
       
Provide safe drinking water for communities
       
Teach children to read, do math or read a map
       
Design and sell clothing
       
Provide advanced education and/or career training for adults
       
Build roads
       
Run a television station
       
Operate an orphanage
       
Provide a place to worship
       
Take care of runaways
       
Operate a club for girls/boys to learn skills and gain leadership opportunities
       
Teach children how to play soccer (baseball, or any other sport)
       

Handout 2Print Handout 2

Definition and Examples of Nonprofit Organizations

A nonprofit organization is formed for the purpose of serving a public or mutual benefit other than the pursuit or accumulation of profits for owners or investors. The nonprofit sector is a collection of organizations that are private (not government); voluntary; and benefit the public.
Examples include, but are not limited to:

  • Charities - e.g. American Red Cross, Salvation Army, YMCA

  • Foundations - e.g., W.K. Kellogg Foundation, Ford Foundation, community foundations

  • Social Welfare or Advocacy Organizations - e.g., National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), National Rifle Association (NRA)

  • Professional/Trade Associations - e.g., Chamber of Commerce, American Medical Association (AMA)

  • Religious Organizations - e.g., churches

Purposes of Nonprofits

According to Lester Salamon (America’s Nonprofit Sector), the author concludes that the nonprofit sector exists to serve four critical functions:

  • Service Provision: Nonprofit organizations provide programs and services to the community. Often times, nonprofits are formed or expanded to react to a community need not being met by the government.

  • Value Guardian: Nonprofit organizations provide a means by which members of a community can take action in an attempt to change the community they live in. These actions may take the form of developing a local neighborhood watch program or, on a larger scale, developing an organization that responds to world relief efforts.

  • Advocacy and Problem Identification: Nonprofit organizations provide a means for drawing public attention to societal issues. Nonprofit organizations make it “possible to identify significant social and political concerns, to give voice to under-represented people and points of view, and to integrate these perspectives into social and political life.”

  • Social Capital: Nonprofit organizations develop a sense of community among the citizens by providing a means to engage in social welfare.

“Definition and Examples of Nonprofit Organizations”
Kate Luckert

http://www.learningtogive.org

Handout 3Print Handout 3

Foundation Poster Rubrics

Directions: Include the following information in designing the foundation poster.

  • Name of the foundation

  • Founder and how he/she showed good character and/or personal virtue

  • Contact information (include Web site if available)

  • Date of founding

  • Short history of the foundation

  • Mission statement or areas of funding interest
Points
Criteria
In order to receive a “4
The poster contains all six required sets of information and is neat, clear and attractive.
In order to receive a “3
The poster contains all four or five required sets of information and is neat, clear and attractive.
In order to receive a “2
The poster contains all three required sets of information and is neat and clear.
In order to receive a “1
The poster contains all two or less required sets of information and is neat.
No credit
The poster is unclear and provides no information for the reader.

 

Philanthropy Framework:

Comments

Catherine, Teacher – Chesaning, MI10/28/2007 9:02:28 PM

(The positive aspect of using this lesson was) students were better able to determine how a mission statement helps determine and maintain focus. It also helped to connect the school setting to the real world setting. It also served to reinforce information previously learned in service learning classes. The rubric for the poster was also very helpful.

Submit a Comment

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.

Copyright © LearningToGive.org